Tuesday, December 22, 2009

Environmental effects


Aerial photograph of Kingston Fossil Plant coal fly ash slurry spill site taken the day after the event

There are a number of adverse environmental effects of coal mining and burning, specially in power stations.

These effects include:

  • Release of carbon dioxide, a greenhouse gas, which causes climate change and global warming according to the IPCC. Coal is the largest contributor to the human-made increase of CO2 in the air.[32]
  • Generation of hundred of millions of tons of waste products, including fly ash, bottom ash, flue gas desulfurization sludge, that contain mercury, uranium, thorium, arsenic, and other heavy metals
  • Acid rain from high sulfur coal
  • Interference with groundwater and water table levels
  • Contamination of land and waterways and destruction of homes from fly ash spills such as Kingston Fossil Plant coal fly ash slurry spill
  • Impact of water use on flows of rivers and consequential impact on other land-uses
  • Dust nuisance
  • Subsidence above tunnels, sometimes damaging infrastructure[citation needed]
  • Coal-fired power plants without effective fly ash capture are one of the largest sources of human-caused background radiation exposure
  • Coal-fired power plants shorten nearly 24,000 lives a year in the United States, including 2,800 from lung cancer.[33]
  • Coal-fired power plant releases emissions including mercury, selenium, and arsenic which are harmful to human health and the environment.[34]

Economic aspects

Coal liquefaction is one of the backstop technologies that could potentially limit escalation of oil prices and mitigate the effects of transportation energy shortage that will occur under peak oil. This is contingent on liquefaction production capacity becoming large enough to satiate the very large and growing demand for petroleum. Estimates of the cost of producing liquid fuels from coal suggest that domestic U.S. production of fuel from coal becomes cost-competitive with oil priced at around 35 USD per barrel,[35] (break-even cost). With oil prices as low as around USD 40 per barrel in the U.S. as of December 15, 2008, liquid coal lost some of its economic allure in the US, but will probably be re-vitalized, similar to oil sand projects, with an oil price around 70$ per barrel.

In China, due to an increasing need for liquid energy in the transportation sector, coal liquefaction were given high priority even during periods of oil prices below 40$ per barrel [36]. This is probably because China prefers not to be dependent on foreign oil, and instead utilize their enormous domestic coal reserves. As oil prices were increasing during the first half of 2009, the coal liquefaction projects in China were again boosted, and these projects are profitable with an oil barrel price of 40$[37].

Among commercially mature technologies, advantage for indirect coal liquefaction over direct coal liquefaction are reported by Williams and Larson (2003).

Intensive research and project developments have been implemented from 2001. The World CTL Award is granted to personalities having brought eminent contribution to the understanding and development of Coal liquefaction. The 2009 presentation ceremony will take place in Washington DC (USA) at the World CTL 2009 Conference (25–27 March 2009).

Energy density

The energy density of coal, i.e. its heating value, is roughly 24 megajoules per kilogram.[38]

The energy density of coal can also be expressed in kilowatt-hours for some unit of mass, the units that electricity is most commonly sold in, to estimate how much coal is required to power electrical appliances. One kilowatt-hour is 3.6 MJ, so the energy density of coal is 6.67 kW·h/kg. The typical thermodynamic efficiency of coal power plants is about 30%, so of the 6.67 kW·h of energy per kilogram of coal, 30% of that—2.0 kW·h/kg—can successfully be turned into electricity; the rest is waste heat. So coal power plants obtain approximately 2.0 kW·h per kilogram of burned coal.

As an example, running one 100 watt lightbulb for one year requires 876 kW·h (100 W × 24 h/day × 365 {days in a year} = 876000 W·h = 876 kW·h). Converting this power usage into physical coal consumption:

\frac{876 \ \mathrm{kW \cdot h}}{2.0 \ \mathrm{kW} \cdot \mathrm{h/kg}} = 438 \ \mathrm{kg \ of \ coal} = 966 \ \mathrm{pounds \ of \ coal}

It takes 438 kg (966 lb) of coal to power a computer for one full year.[39] One should also take into account transmission and distribution losses caused by resistance and heating in the power lines, which is in the order of 5–10%, depending on distance from the power station and other factors.

Carbon intensity

Commercial coal has a carbon content of at least 70%. Coal with a heating value of 6.67 kWh per kilogram as quoted above has a carbon content of roughly 80%, which is

 \frac{0.8 \ \mathrm{kg}}{\mathrm{12} \cdot \mathrm{kg/kmol}} = \frac{2}{30} \ \mathrm{kmol} , where 1 mol equals to NA (Avogadro Number) atoms.

Carbon combines with oxygen in the atmosphere during combustion, producing carbon dioxide, with an atomic weight of (12 + 16 × 2 = 44 kg/kmol). The CO2 released to air for each kilogram of incinerated coal is therefore

\frac{2}{30} \ \mathrm{kmol} \cdot \frac{44 \ \mathrm{kg}}{\mathrm{kmol}} = \frac{88}{30} \ \mathrm{kg} \approx 2.93 \ \mathrm{kg}.

This can be used to calculate an emission factor for CO2 from the use of coal power. Since the useful energy output of coal is about 30% of the 6.67 kWh/kg(coal), the burning of 1 kg of coal produces about 2 kWh of electrical energy. Since 1 kg coal emits 2.93 kg CO2, the direct CO2 emissions from coal power are 1.47 kg/kWh, or about 0.407 kg/MJ.

The U.S. Energy Information Agency's 1999 report on CO2 emissions for energy generation,[40] quotes a lower emission factor of 0.963 kg CO2/kWh for coal power. The same source gives factor for oil power in the U.S. of 0.881 kg CO2/kWh, while natural gas has 0.569 kg CO2/kWh. Estimates for specific emission from nuclear power, hydro, and wind energy vary, but are about 100 times lower, see environmental effects of nuclear power.

Underground fires

Most underground fires are caused by the mineral marcasite.[citation needed] chemical formula FeS2, it is chemically, the same as pyrite (fool's gold) but structurally complex. Marcasite and pyrite very commonly occur in association with coal beds. these minerals form the source of the sulphur which occurs within the coal. Marcasite is highly unstable at pressures and temperatures close to the earths surface. Due to its unstable nature, it may react spontaneously, consuming itself and releasing heat. In the event that sufficient heat is generated and coal occurs close by, the coal may be set alight underground and such a blaze may go on burning for tens to hundreds of years.

There are hundreds of coal fires burning around the world.[41] Those burning underground can be difficult to locate and many cannot be extinguished. Fires can cause the ground above to subside, their combustion gases are dangerous to life, and breaking out to the surface can initiate surface wildfires. Coal seams can be set on fire by spontaneous combustion or contact with a mine fire or surface fire. A grass fire in a coal area can set dozens of coal seams on fire.[42][43] Coal fires in China burn 109 million tons of coal a year, emitting 360 million metric tons of CO2. This contradicts the ratio of 1:1.83 given earlier, but it amounts to 2-3% of the annual worldwide production of CO2 from fossil fuels, or as much as emitted from all of the cars and light trucks in the United States.[44][45] In Centralia, Pennsylvania (a borough located in the Coal Region of the United States) an exposed vein of coal ignited in 1962 due to a trash fire in the borough landfill, located in an abandoned anthracite strip mine pit. Attempts to extinguish the fire were unsuccessful, and it continues to burn underground to this day. The Australian Burning Mountain was originally believed to be a volcano, but the smoke and ash comes from a coal fire which may have been burning for over 5,500 years.[46]

At Kuh i Malik in Yagnob Valley, Tajikistan, coal deposits have been burning for thousands of years, creating vast underground labyrinths full of unique minerals, some of them very beautiful. Local people once used this method to mine ammoniac. This place has been well-known since the time of Herodotus, but European geographers misinterpreted the Ancient Greek descriptions as the evidence of active volcanism in Turkestan (up to the 19th century, when the Russian army invaded the area).

The reddish siltstone rock that caps many ridges and buttes in the Powder River Basin (Wyoming), and in western North Dakota is called porcelanite, which also may resemble the coal burning waste "clinker" or volcanic "scoria".[47] Clinker is rock that has been fused by the natural burning of coal. In the Powder River Basin approximately 27 to 54 billion tons of coal burned within the past three million years.[48] Wild coal fires in the area were reported by the Lewis and Clark Expedition as well as explorers and settlers in the area.[49]

Production trends


Coal output in 2005

A coal mine in Wyoming, United States. The United States has the world's largest coal reserves.

In 2006, China was the top producer of coal with 38% share followed by the USA and India, reports the British Geological Survey.

World coal reserves

At the end of 2006 the recoverable coal reserves amounted around 800 or 900 gigatons. The United States Energy Information Administration gives world reserves as 930 billion short tons[50] (equal to 843 gigatons) as of 2006. At the current extraction rate, this would last 132 years.[51] However, the rate of coal consumption is annually increasing at 2-3% per year and, setting the growth rate to 2.5% yields an exponential depletion time of 56 years (in 2065).[52] At the current global total energy consumption of 15.7 terawatts,[53] there is enough coal to provide the entire planet with all of its energy for 37 years (assuming 0% growth in demand and ignoring transportation's need for liquid fuels).[original research?]

The 930 billion short tons of recoverable coal reserves estimated by the Energy Information Administration are equal to about 4,116 BBOE (billion barrels of oil equivalent).[citation needed] The amount of coal burned during 2007 was estimated at 7.075 billion short tons, or 133.179 quadrillion BTU's.[54] In terms of heat content, this is about 57 million barrels of oil equivalent per day. By comparison in 2007, natural gas provided 51 million barrels of oil equivalent per day, while oil provided 85.8 million barrels per day.

British Petroleum, in its annual report 2007, estimated at 2006 end, there were 909,064 million tons of proven coal reserves worldwide, or 147 years reserves-to-production ratio. This figure only includes reserves classified as "proven"; exploration drilling programs by mining companies, particularly in under-explored areas, are continually providing new reserves. In many cases, companies are aware of coal deposits that have not been sufficiently drilled to qualify as "proven". However, some nations haven't updated their information and assume reserves remain at the same levels even with withdrawals.


Continental United States coal regions

Of the three fossil fuels coal has the most widely distributed reserves; coal is mined in over 100 countries, and on all continents except Antarctica. The largest reserves are found in the USA, Russia, Australia, China, India and South Africa.

Note the table below.

Proved recoverable coal reserves at end-2006 (million tonnes (teragrams))[55]
Country ↓ Bituminous & anthracite ↓ SubBituminous & lignite ↓ TOTAL ↓ Share ↓
USA 111,338 135,305 246,643 27.1
Russian Federation 49,088 107,922 157,010 17.3
China 62,200 52,300 114,500 12.6
India 90,085 2,360 92,445 10.2
Australia 38,600 39,900 78,500 8.6
South Africa 48,750 0 48,750 5.4
Ukraine 16,274 17,879 34,153 3.8
Kazakhstan 28,151 3,128 31,279 3.4
Poland 14,000 0 14,000 1.5
Brazil 0 10,113 10,113 1.1
Germany 183 6,556 6,739 0.7
Colombia 6,230 381 6,611 0.7
Canada 3,471 3,107 6,578 0.7
Czech Republic 2,094 3,458 5,552 0.6
Indonesia 740 4,228 4,968 0.5
Turkey 278 3,908 4,186 0.5
Greece 0 3,900 3,900 0.4
Hungary 198 3,159 3,357 0.4
Pakistan 0 3,050 3,050 0.3
Bulgaria 4 2,183 2,187 0.2
Thailand 0 1,354 1,354 0.1
Mexico 860 351 1,211 0.1
North Korea 300 300 600 0.1
New Zealand 33 538 571 0.1
Spain 200 330 530 0.1
Zimbabwe 502 0 502 0.1
Romania 22 472 494 0.1
Venezuela 479 0 479 0.1
All others 4,691 24,111 28,802 3.2
TOTAL 478,771 430,293 909,064 100
  • Recent discoveries of lignite in the Thar region of Pakistan have given rise to additional reserves of nearly 185 billion tonnes.[56]

[edit] Major coal producers

The reserve life is an estimate based only on current production levels for the countries shown, and makes no assumptions of future production or even current production trends.

Production of Coal by Country and year (million tonnes)[55]
Country ↓ 2003 ↓ 2004 ↓ 2005 ↓ 2006 ↓ Share ↓ Reserve Life (years) ↓
China 1722.0 1992.3 2204.7 2380.0 38.4 % 48
USA 972.3 1008.9 1026.5 1053.6 17.0 % 234
India 375.4 407.7 428.4 447.3 7.2 % 207
Australia 351.5 366.1 378.8 373.8 6.0 % 210
Russia 276.7 281.7 298.5 309.2 5.0 % 508
South Africa 237.9 243.4 244.4 256.9 4.1 % 190
Germany 204.9 207.8 202.8 197.2 3.2 % 34
Indonesia 114.3 132.4 146.9 195.0 3.1 % 25
Poland 163.8 162.4 159.5 156.1 2.5 % 90
Total World 5187.6 5585.3 5886.7 6195.1 100 % 142

If continuous growth in usage at the rate of the years 2003 to 2006 from the table above (6.0948% pa compound) is assumed, reserves would be exhausted in 31 years.

[edit] Major coal exporters

Exports of Coal by Country and year (million short tons)[57][58]
Country ↓ 2003 ↓ 2004 ↓ 2005 ↓ Share ↓
Australia 238.1 247.6 257.6 32.0%
Indonesia 107.8 131.4 147.6 13.4%
China 103.4 95.5 79.0 9.8%
South Africa 78.7 74.9 77.5 9.6%
Russia 41.0 55.7 62.3 .7.7%
USA 43.0 48.0 49.9 6.2%
Canada 27.7 28.8 31.0 3.9%
Poland 16.4 16.3 16.4 2.0%
Vietnam N/A 10.3 14.1 1.8%
Total 713.9 764.0 804.2 100%

No comments:

Post a Comment